Skip to decisions
Žuk — ANTON и JELENA
Back to decisions

Association waived its claim after debt payment; court awarded part of the costs

Viru Maakohus · First instance

Apartment association bills, payments and debtsDebt claimsObligations of multiple owners

Association waived its claim after debt payment; court awarded part of the costs

Ruling · Viru Maakohus · First instance

Tallinna mnt 42 Korteriühistu · 80054903

Entry into force has not been reverified

Participants and roles: claimant – apartment association; two defendants XX – joint owners; association representative XX

How it started · editorial summary

The court ended the case after the association waived its claim because the debt had been paid. It awarded 137,50 euros* in costs jointly and severally against two defendants.

The dispute and the court’s decision

The court accepted the apartment association Tallinna mnt 42’s waiver of its claim against two defendants XX and terminated proceedings. The waiver followed payment of the claimed debt after the association went to court. The defendants did not object. The court found the waiver permissible and explained that the same claim against the same defendants on the same grounds could not be brought again. As payment after filing caused the waiver, litigation costs were imposed on the defendants. They are jointly and severally liable: the association may seek the awarded sum from both together or either one within the overall total. The court awarded the association 137,50 euros*, half the fee paid for the payment order application and transition to ordinary civil proceedings. The other costs claimed were not considered necessary and justified. In particular, the association participated without a contractual representative, so expenses for drafting the claim, consultation and signing the agreement were not accepted; bank charges and separate payment order costs were also not awarded. The court fee refund question was left for a separate ruling after this ruling becomes final. The ruling itself does not confirm payment of the awarded litigation costs.

Outcome of this decision

Terminate proceedings following waiver of the claim. Award 137,50 euros* in litigation costs jointly and severally against the defendants; the court fee refund is to be decided separately.
Translation of an anonymised, abridged excerpt from Estonian
4. The court will decide the refund of litigation costs by a separate ruling after the court ruling becomes final.